P&L Clear-up – Obligations and Swaps Tony Morris antony. [email protected] com MICS – DKS Manila Contents 1. Obligation Pricing – basic concepts 2. P&L sensitivities of a obligation i. PV01 ii. CS01 iii. Theta iv. Propel 3. Extension to carepresentation admonish swaps 1. Obligation Pricing – basic concepts Let’s repeat you keep a 4 year 10% annual coupon obligation, with a grant (‘grant to ripeness’ or ‘grant to redemption’) of 12%. From this connectable attributable attributableification, the esteem can be fitted as 93. 93%. The esteem is fitted by pricing each of the obligation’s capital issues using the grant to ripeness (YTM) as a remittance admonish.
Why? Accordingly the YTM is disuniteicularized as the admonish which, if stateationd to remittance the obligation’s capital issues, gives its esteem. We could delineate it approve this: Obligation Capital Issues on a Presageal Scale Each agricultural coupon of 10% is remittanceed tail to today by the grant to ripeness of 12%: 93. 93% = 10 + 10 + 10 + 110 (1. 12)1 (1. 12)2 (1. 12)3 (1. 12)4 Whole we are doing is observing the grant in the trade and solving ce the esteem. Substitutenatively, we could effort extinguished the grant if we keep the esteem from the trade.
Obligation esteem calculators effort by iteratively solving ce the grant to ripeness. Ce a obligation trading at par, the grant to ripeness and coupon procure be the selfsame, e. g. a immodest year obligation with a agricultural coupon of 10% and a grant of 10% would be trading at 100%. Silence that obligation esteems go down as grants go up and obligation esteems go up as grants go down. This inverse entombdependence among obligation esteems and grants is fairly spontaneous. Ce our par obligation balance, if immodest year trade grants droop to 9% investors procure be procureing to secure balance than par to suborn the balance trade coupons of 10%. This procure cece its esteem up until it, so, grants 9%.
If grants loosen to, repeat, 11% investors procure barely be procureing to secure near than par ce the obligation accordingly its coupon is lowerneath the trade. Ce a minute pattern of the obligation pricing sort, distinguish Appendix 3. Ce now, silence that the tiny esteem of a obligation is the consoliconclusion of the confer-upon esteems of the capital issues in the obligation. The esteem named in the trade, the so-named “clean” esteem or trade esteem, is in deed connectable attributable attributable attributable the confer-upon esteem of finishedthing. It is barely an accountants’ gathering. The trade esteem, or purified esteem, is the confer-upon esteem near accrued carepresentation according to the trade gathering. . P&L sensitivities of a obligation As we maxim balance, the esteem of a obligation can be sturdy if we lowerstand its capital issues and the remittance admonish (i. e. YTM) at which to confer-upon esteem them. The grant flexion from which are conservative the remittance deedors ce a obligation can itself be pondered as the consoliconclusion of couple flexions: 1. the “underlying” grant flexion (normally Libor), and 2. the “credit” flexion i. e. the diffrepresentation balance the lowerlying flexion The sensitivity of the obligation esteem to a exalter in these couple flexions is named: i. PV01, and ii. CS01 honorively.
Related essay: “Support Real Promote Insertion Ce Personals”
In stipulations of the pattern balance, the remittance admonish of 12% restraintce be meek down into, repeat, a Libor admonish of 7% conjointly with a reputation diffrepresentation of 5%. (Note, in the behindcited, it is great connectable attributable attributable attributable to disorder the remittance admonish, which is an annualised grant, and the remittance deedor, which is the upshot of coalescenceing the remittance admonish balance the ripeness in entombrogation. ) In adduction to the sensitivities descriptive balance, we can as-well ponder the collision on the esteem of the obligation of a undivided day contraction in ripeness. Such a contraction favors the esteem ce couple reasons: ) coxcombical the grant flexion isn’t mawkish, the remittance admonishs procure exalter accordingly, in open, the remittance admonish ce presageal “t” is connectable attributable attributable attributable the selfselfalike as that ce presageal “t-1” b) past undivided day has gone-by, whatever the remittance admonish, we procure coalescence it naturalized on a presageal gap that is weaker by undivided day The names loving to these couple sensitivities are, honorively:
Theta, and Propel Silence that, of these immodest sensitivities, barely the primeval couple, i. e. PV01 and CS01, are “trade sensitivities” in the meaning that they tally to sensitivities to substitutes in trade parameters.
Theta and Propel are refractory of any exalter in the trade and ponder incongruous aspects of the sensitivity to the avenue of presageal. i)PV01 Specification The PV01 of a obligation is disuniteicularized as the confer-upon esteem collision of a 1 carepresentation aim (0. 01%) extension (or “bump”) in the grant flexion. In the disuniteition lowerneath, we procure connect to a collective “remittance flexion”. As silenced prior, this remittance flexion, from which are conservative the remittance deedors ce the obligation pricing controlethought, can itself be pondered as the consoliconclusion of couple flexions: the “underlying” grant flexion (normally Libor), and a reputation flexion (meditation the promote balance and balance the entombbank promote ncorporated in the Libor flexion). The PV01 apportions the collision on the esteem of bumping the lowerlying grant flexion. Controlethought Ce frankness, ponder the plight of a cipher coupon obligation i. e. where there is barely undivided capital issue, resembling to the finishedenance esteem, and occurring at ripeness in n years. Silence, though, that the principles of the behindcited disuniteition procure resemblingly wholeot to a coupon secureing obligation. We begin by defining: P = esteem or confer-upon esteem today R(t) = remittance admonish, today, ce ripeness t FV = finishedenance esteem of the obligation Then, from the balance, we lowerstand:
P = FV/(1+r(t))^n Now ponder the collision a 1bp bump to this flexion. The remittance admonish becomes: R(t) = R(t) + 0. 0001 The innovating esteem of the obligation, Pb(t), procure be: Pb = FV/(1+[r(t)+. 0001])^n Coercion-this-reason, the sensitivity of this obligation to a 1bp extension to the remittance flexion procure be: Pb – P = FV/(1+[r(t)+. 0001])^n – FV/(1+r(t))^n Eqn. 1 The primeval presageal is regularly trivialer than the prevent presageal, coercion-this-reason: * if we rest the obligation (desire posn), the PV01 is disclaiming * if we keep weak sold the obligation (weak posn), the PV01 is real We can as-well distinguish that: the loftier the grant (remittance admonish), the trivialer the PV01. This is accordingly a agitate in the remittance admonish from, ce pattern, 8. 00% to 8. 01% states a trivialer referable attributable attributable attributable attributable attributable attributable attributable attributable-irresponsible exalter than from 3. 00% to 3. 01%. In other control, the loftier the grant, the near perceptive is the obligation esteem to an irresponsible exalter in the grant * the desireer the ripeness, the bigger the PV01. This is balance self-evident – the desireer the ripeness, the bigger the coalescenceing deedor that is applied to the extransitional remittance admonish, coercion-this-reason the bigger the collision it procure keep.
To growth this habit to a coupon secureing obligation, we barely silence that any obligation can be pondered as a succession of personal capital issues. The PV01 of each capital issue is fitted as balance, by bumping the lowerlying grant flexion at the tallying ripeness. In sort, where a portfolio contains frequent obligations, it would connectable attributable attributable attributable be serviceable, nor succumb conducive connectable attributable attributableification, to keep a PV01 ce finished unmarried capital issue. Coercion-this-reason the capital issues opposing whole the lies are bucketed into incongruous maturities. The PV01 is fitted on a bucketed carepresentation i. e. by farsighted the collision of a 1bp bump to the grant flexion on each bucket personally.
This is an bearing barring enables the trafficker to handle his promote lie by having a handle ce his balancewhole peril at each of a succession of maturities. Typical bucketing restraintce be: o/n, 1wk, 1m, 2m, 3m, 6m, 9m, 1y, 2y, 3y, 5y, 10y, 15y, 20y, 30y. Efforted pattern: Arrogate we rest $10m connectable attributable attributableional of a cipher-coupon obligation maturing in 7 years and the grant to ripeness is 8%. Silence that, ce a cipher coupon obligation, the YTM is, by specification, the selfselfalike as the remittance admonish to be applied to the (bullet) securement at ripeness. We keep: Esteem, P = $10m / (1. 08)^7 = $5. 834m
Bumping the flexion by 1bp, the “bumped esteem” becomes: Pb = $10m / (1. 0801)^7 = $5. 831m Coercion-this-reason, the PV01 is: Pb – P = $5. 831m – $5. 835m = -$0. 004m (or -$4k) Meaning In the pattern balance, we keep fitted the PV01 of the obligation to be -$4k. This utensil that, if the lowerlying grant flexion were to extension from its exhibit plane of 8% to 8. 01%, the lie would convert in esteem by $4k. If we arrogate the admonish of exalter in esteem of the obligation with honor to the grant is regular, then we can apportion the collision of, ce pattern, a 5bp bump to the grant flexion to be 5 x -$4k = -$20k.
Note, this is barely an bearing; if we were to graph the obligation esteem finisheder its grant, we wouldn’t distinguish a right course barring a flexion. This non-linear commodities is named protuberance. In sort, suitableness ce smwhole substitutes in the grant the bearing is efficient, ce bigger substitutes, protuberance canreferable attributable be ignored. Ce pattern, if the grant were to extension to 9%, the collision on the esteem would be -$365k, connectable attributable attributable attributable -(8%-9%)x$4k = -$400k. Stateation The concept of PV01 is of life-containing day to day presageification to the trafficker. In sort, he handles his trading portfolio by monitoring the bucketed grant flexion peril as explicit by PV01.
Where he handles the PV01 is so enlightened, he procure fulfil a proceeding purposed to either mawkishten or convert the promote. Alikely, when he has a vision as to advenient grant flexion agitatements, he procure lie his PV01 peril to stateation custom of them. In this plight, he is insertion a trading lie. ii)CS01 The carepresentation of the CS01 controlethought is selfselfselfselfidentical to that of the PV01, barely this presageal we bump the reputation diffrepresentation rather than the lowerlying grant flexion. The balance pattern was naturalized on a collective remittance admonish. In sort, ce any obligation other than a promote munificent undivided, this admonish procure be concert of the grant flexion conjointly with the reputation flexion.
At primeval glance coercion-this-reason, we would coercionebode that, whether we bump the grant flexion or the reputation diffrepresentation by 1bp, the collision on the esteem should be alike, and descriptive by Eqn. 1 balance. What we can as-well repeat is that, bumping the grant flexion, the balancewhole remittance admonish procure extension and coercion-this-reason, as ce PV01: * if we rest the obligation (desire posn), the CS01 is disclaiming * if we keep weak sold the obligation (weak posn), the CS01 is real From the selfselfalike ponderations as ce PV01, we can distinguish that: * the loftier the reputation diffuse, the trivialer the CS01 * the desireer the ripeness, the bigger the CS01
In sort, when we contemplate at multiple capital issues, the collision of a 1bp bump in the grant flexion is connectable attributable attributable attributable selfselfselfselfidentical to a 1bp bump in the reputation diffuse. This is accordingly, entomb alia: * the flexions are connectable attributable attributable attributable the selfselfalike mould and coercion-this-reason entombpolations procure disagree * bumping the reputation diffrepresentation favors want presumption assumptions that procure, in alter, collision the obligation esteem In open though, PV01 and CS01 ce a agricultural coupon obligation procure be alike. The exclusion is where the obligation secures a discurrent admonish coupon. In this plight, the sensitivity to grant flexion substitutes is obstruct to cipher so, although the PV01 procure be very trivial, the CS01 procure be “normal”.
Worked pattern: A efforted pattern would supervene the selfselfalike steps as ce PV01 balance, barely this presageal we would bump the reputation diffrepresentation by 1bp rather than the lowerlying grant flexion. Theta and Propel We now contemplate at the couple sensitivities arising from the avenue of presageal (“1 day decay”, to stateation liberty pricing presagealinology). Primeval, let’s apportion what the finished collision on the esteem of a lie would be if the barely exalter were that undivided day had passed. In feature, we arrogate that the grant and reputation flexions are unnatural. Again, ce frankness, ponder the plight of a cipher coupon obligation i. . where there is barely undivided capital issue, resembling to the finishedenance esteem, and occurring at ripeness in n years. Again, we silence that the principles of the behindcited disuniteition procure resemblingly wholeot to a coupon secureing obligation. Behindcited the earlier connectable attributable attributableation, the esteem (or esteem) today procure be: P(today) = FV/(1+r(t))^n The esteem tomorrow procure be: P(tomorrow) = FV/(1+r(t-1))^(n-1/365)Eqn. 2 There are couple disagreeences among the cemula ce the esteem today and that ce tomorrow. Primevally, the remittance admonish has agitated from r(t) to r(t-1). Here, r(t-1) is the remittance admonish ce ripeness (t-1) today.
We keep arrogated that the remittance flexion does connectable attributable attributable attributable agitate day on day, coercion-this-reason the admonish at which the capital issue procure be remittanceed tomorrow is the admonish tallying to a undivided day weaker ripeness, today. Prevently, the continuance balance which we remittance the capital issues has convertd by undivided day, from n to n-1/365 (we disunite by 365 accordingly n is enacted in years). Theta and Propel take these couple deedors. P(tomorrow) – P(today) gives the bountiful collision on the esteem ascribable to the perishing of undivided day. This collision can be approachd by breaking down the balance cemula into its couple content cleverness i. e. he exalter in remittance admonish and the exalter in ripeness, as clear-uped lowerneath. iii)Theta As anteriorly, we disuniteicularize: P = esteem or confer-upon esteem today r(t) = remittance admonish, today, ce ripeness t FV = finishedenance esteem of the obligation In adduction, we disuniteicularize: r(t-1) = remittance admonish, today, ce ripeness t-1 (e. g. ce a obligation with 240 days to ripeness, if the 240 day remittance admonish today is 8. 00% and the 239 day remittance admonish today is 7. 96% then: r(t) = 8. 00% and r(t-1) = 7. 96%) We now disuniteicularize Theta as: FV/(1+r(t-1))^n – FV/(1+r(t))^n We can distinguish that, assimilated to the cemula ce the bountiful esteem collision balance (Eqn. ), this sensitivity ponders the exalter in the remittance admonish barring ignores the contraction by 1 day of the ripeness. In other control, Theta states the esteem collision ascribable purely to the exalter in remittance admonish upshoting from a 1 day weaker ripeness barring ignores the collision on the coalescenceing deedor of the remittance admonish upshoting from the weaker ripeness. Silence that the presage of Theta, in dissimilarity to PV01 and CS01, can be twain real and disclaiming. This is accordingly r(t-1) can be loftier or inferior than r(t), resting on the mould of the grant flexion.
That said, in sort, loving that grant flexions are normally upward sloping, we would coercionebode r(t) to be loftier than r(t-1). Coercion-this-reason Theta procure normally be real. In the selfselfalike habit, if the grant flexion is mawkish, then Theta procure be cipher. iv)Propel Using the model connectable attributable attributableation, we disuniteicularize Propel as: FV/(1+r(t))^(n-1) – FV/(1+r(t))^n Comparing to the cemula ce the bountiful esteem collision balance (Eqn. 2), we distinguish that this sensitivity ponders the exalter in ripeness on the coalescenceing deedor to be applied to the remittance admonish barring ignores the collision on the remittance admonish itself of tender undivided day down the flexion.
In other control, Propel states the esteem collision ascribable purely to the exalter in remittance deedor upshoting from a 1 day weaker coalescenceing continuance barring ignores the collision on the remittance admonish upshoting from the weaker ripeness. Where remittance admonishs are real (r(t) > 0), Propel procure regularly be real past the primeval presageal procure be enlightenedr than the prevent. Using the Taylor expatiation, we can obtain a simplified approach esteem ce Propel. Remembering that: 1/(1+x)^n = 1 – n. x + (1/2). n. (n-1). x^2 – … we keep: Propel = FV. 1-(n-1/365). r(t)) – FV. (1-n. r(t)) = FV. r(t). 1/365 Silence that r(t). 1/365 would reconfer-upon undivided day’s “interest” fitted on an accruals carepresentation past, in the plight, the grant resemblings the coupon admonish. (Note, where a lie is accounted ce on an accruals cause, and coercion-this-reason esteemd at par, the grant procure regularly resembling the coupon. ) In other control, this specification ties in to the spontaneous conception of propel that we keep from, repeat, a guard where the propel would be resembling to undivided day’s cause, naturalized on its coupon.
We can as-well distinguish that Propel is promptly proportional to the grant. We keep now distinguishn that, among them, Theta and Propel try to take the couple contents solemn the esteem agitate arising from the perishing of 1 day, whole other deedors life kept regular. There procure be sure “cross” commoditiess of the couple that procure connectable attributable attributable attributable be taked when fulfiling this dissection. In other control, Theta + Propel procure connectable attributable attributable attributable precisely resembling the bountiful collision (as per Eqn. 2). The disagreeence, at-last, procure connectable attributable attributable attributable normally be symbolical.
In open, ce a desire obligation lie, twain Theta and Propel procure be real as, with the perishing of undivided day, connectable attributable attributable attributable barely procure the annualised remittance admonish be near (meditation the inferior grant normally required ce weaker conclusiond utensils) barring the coalescenceing deedor procure be trivialer (meditation the weaker ripeness). Efforted pattern: Arrogate we rest $10m connectable attributable attributableional of a cipher-coupon obligation maturing in 240 days and the grant to ripeness today is 8%. As-well, the grant today ce the 239 day ripeness is 7. 96%. Theta = $10m/(1. 0796)^(240/365) – $10m/(1. 08)^(240/365) = $23,159 Propel = $10m/(1. 8)^(239/365) – $10m/(1. 08)^(240/365) $20,047 Theta + Propel = $43,205 To assimilate, the bountiful esteem collision of a 1 day “decay” is: $10m/(1. 076)^(239/365) – $10m/(1. 08)^(240/365) = $43,113 Consolidatemary We keep now analysed the explanation sensitivities that clear-up the 1 day agitate in a obligation’s referablee to trade esteem. To consolidatemaloosen some of the deep features; ce a desire obligation lie:
PV01 / CS01: disclaiming ce a agricultural coupon or cipher coupon obligation, PV01 and CS01 procure be alike the loftier the grant/reputation diffuse, the trivialer the PV01/CS01
the desireer the ripeness, the bigger the PV01/CS01 ce a discurrent admonish coupon (with a Libor benchmark), PV01 procure be very smwhole barring the CS01 procure be “normal” Theta real the mawkishter the flexion, the trivialer the Theta Propel * real * proportional to the grant Extension to carepresentation admonish swaps In nature, whole the balance applies resemblingly to carepresentation admonish swaps (IRSs) when farsighted/explaining daily P&L. We begin by connectable attributable attributableing that an IRS is barely the exexalter of couple capital issues, undivided agricultural and undivided discurrent. Growthing the disuniteition we made ce obligations, we can repeat: a) The PV01 of the discurrent admonish leg procure be obstruct to cipher. This is as silenced ce a discurrent admonish obligation.
In twain plights, as the grant flexion substitutes so do the coercionebodeed advenient capital issues barring, at the selfselfalike presageal, so procure the remittance admonishs at which they are PV’d. The couple commoditiess procure broadly repeal extinguished. (The PV01 procure connectable attributable attributable attributable be precisely cipher accordingly, unintermittently the Libor fixing occurs, the instant capital issue becomes agricultural and coercion-this-reason commoditiesively becomes a cipher coupon obligation, on which there procure be PV01. ) The agricultural leg is alike to the agricultural coupon drift on a obligation and can be pondered as a succession of cipher coupon obligations. Coercion-this-reason the suitable selfselfalike disuniteition as applied to obligations balance procure wholeot to the agricultural leg. An IRS that ays discurrent and receives agricultural procure keep a PV01 sensitivity alike to that of a desire obligation lie. c) IRSs are normally entombbank trades where it is arrogated that there is no reputation promote balance and balance Libor. Coercion-this-reason, the CS01 procure be cipher. Theta and Propel may be either real or disclaiming.
Appendix 1 : Conclusion Gatherings There are various habits ce computing the carepresentation secureable in a continuance and the accrued carepresentation ce a continuance. A feature habit applied to a proceeding can favor the grant of that proceeding and as-well the securement ce a proceeding. Finisheding the Reckon of Days
The gatherings stateationd to disuniteicularize the carepresentation securements rest on couple deedors: 1) The reckon of days in a continuance and 2) The reckon of days in a year. The gatherings are: 0 Real/360 1 Real/365 : casually connectred as Real/365F (infrequently stateationd now) 2 Real/Real 3 30/360 European: casually connectred to as ISMA habit (30E/360) 4 30/360 US (30U/360) The primeval three habits (Actual/360, Real/365 and Real/Actual) apportion the reckon of days in a continuance by finisheding the real reckon of days. Ce each habit the reckon of days in a year is incongruous. Real/365 and Real/Real are alike except: 1.
Periods which comprise February 29th (bounce year) finished the reckon of days in a year as 365 lower Act/365 and 366 lower Act/Act; 2. Semi-annual continuances are arrogated to keep 182. 5 days lower Act/365 and at-last frequent real days lower Act/Act. Euroobligation trades stateation the 30E/360 cause. This controlethought arrogates finished month has 30 days. This utensil that the 31st of a month is regularly finisheded as if it were the 30th of the month. Ce 30E/360 cause, February is as-well arrogated to keep 30 days. If the opening or purpose of a continuance droops on a weekpurpose the coupon is connectable attributable attributable attributable adjusted to a good-tempered-tempered calling day.
This utensil that there are regularly precisely 360 days in a year ce whole coupons. Ce pattern a coupon from 08-November-1997 to 08-November-1998 of 5% is a coupon of 5%, equal though 08-November-1998 is a Sunday. There is no commutation to the real coupon securement.
Appendix 2 : Farsighted Accrued Carepresentation Equal though Euroobligation coupons are connectable attributable attributable attributable adjusted ce weekends and holidays, the accrual of a coupon ce any disunite of the year has to stateation the ampurpose reckon of days. The disagreeence among European and US 30/360 habit is how the purpose of the month is treated. Ce US carepresentation the 31st of a month is treated as the 1st of the instant month, unnear the continuance is from 30th or 31st of the earlier month.
Euro money trades: 0 Day finished cause: real/360 1 Location cause: dishonor (couple day) model 2 Fixing continuance ce derivatives contracts: couple day admonish fixing gathering Euro FX trades 3 Location timing: dishonor gathering, with carepresentation accrual opening on the prevent day behind the dispense has been struck 4 Quotation: ‘Sure ce uncertain’ (ie 1 Euro = x ceeign circulation units) U. S.
In the plight of Bunds, the day-finished gathering is the Act/Act gathering. Appendix 1 contains balance elements of conclusion gatherings – it is recommended that you learn this at the purpose of the module. The disunite of a year among the location conclusion (27 July 2001) and the instant coupon (4 February 2002) is: Day Finished 192/365 (ie Real days/Real days) = 0. 5260 The esteem of the primeval coupon can coercion-this-reason be fitted in the behindcited habit: PV of Primeval Coupon = 4. 8873% Whole of the other capital issue confer-upon esteems are fitted in the selfselfalike sort. Adding them up gives us the esteem of the obligation.
Accrued carepresentation is fitted from 04 February 2001 to 27 July 2001 (173 days) : Accrued Carepresentation Accrued = 5% x 0. 47397 = 2. 3699% There is balance element on Accrued carepresentation in Appendix 2. It is recommended that you learn it at the purpose of this module. Connectable attributable attributableice that the named esteem of the obligation (the ‘purified esteem’) is 102. 2651% connectable attributable attributable attributable 104. 6350% (which is the ‘tiny esteem’ or invoice esteem – ie the esteem really hired ce the obligation). The tiny esteem is the consoliconclusion of the confer-upon esteems of the capital issues in the obligation. The esteem named in the trade, the so-named “clean” esteem or trade esteem, is in deed connectable attributable attributable attributable the confer-upon esteem of finishedthing.
It is barely an accountants’ gathering. The trade esteem, or purified esteem, is the confer-upon esteem near accrued carepresentation according to the trade gathering. Practitioners experience it easier to name the purified esteem accordingly it abstracts from the changing daily accrued carepresentation (i. e. it avoids a “saw-toothed” esteem feature). This proclamation is ce entombnal stateation barely by Deutsche Bank Global Trades employees. The symbolical (including cemulae and diffusesheets) is succumbd ce knowledge purposes barely and should lower no term be stateationd ce client pricing.
Examples, plight studies, exercises and solutions may stateation simplifying assumptions that do connectable attributable attributable attributable wholeot in sort, and may disagree from Deutsche Bank proprietary models really stateationd. The proclamation is succumbd to you solely ce connectable attributable attributableification purposes and is connectable attributable attributable attributable calculated as an extend or process ce the lapse or sale of any financial utensil or issue. The connectable attributable attributableification contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be legitimate, barring is connectable attributable attributable attributable necessarily finished and its exactness canreferable attributable be guaranteed.